healthcare plans. There were half a dozen people in the back of the
room with signs declaring "Healthcare now!" the rest of the 200+
people at the event however were opposed to socialised healthcare.
There were three panelists: an MD in favour or tort reform, a policy  
analyst (from Grassroot Institute of Hawaii) promoting reform, but not  
by public option or employer mandate (where employers are forced to  
provide health insurance to their workers), and a representative from  
the AARP who was in favour of Obama's plan.
Linda Rasmussen, the speaker for tort reform had some good arguments,  
but she seemed willing to be fine with any side of the debate as long  
as it included tort reform. Though I can see that tort reform may be  
valuable, as I have researched a bit on the impact it has had in Texas  
by bringing more doctors to the state, I do not believe that it would  
redeem a socialised system.
The represntative of the AARP, Bruce Bottorff, faced a very tough  
crowd, and was often booed for his statements. Yes it may have been  
rude, which is why I abstained from doing so, they were generally  
called for. If someone lies about things in a statement it is  
understandable that this would be upsetting. Bottorff gave "myths"  
about Obama's plan and would then simply say that they were false,  
with no real rationale or proof that this was the case. For example,  
there was the myth that Obama's plan would lead to rationing. He  
attacked this saying that this was not going to happen because there  
was nothing about it in the bill. This is not a solid argument at all,  
because even if there is no mention of rationing in the bill, it is  
still a possible consequence of a socialised healthcare system. It  
cannot be prevented in a clause of the bill just as competition cannot  
be created in a clause of a bill. As much as legislators would wish it  
to be so, things never happen exactly as they are foreseen, which is  
why the strict codes of government legislation do not work. In the  
private sector there are feasibility studies to make predictions as to  
how things will work, but actions are still left up to adjustment in  
case things do not work exactly as planned.


1 comment:
Kenli, when its your turn to run for president for the Libertarian party, you'll have my full support.
Post a Comment